AFib
Two heart surgeons checking information on a monitor

Concomitant Surgical Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation (AFib)

Concomitant surgical ablation, also called concomitant ablation, is a surgical treatment for atrial fibrillation (AFib) that is performed simultaneously with other heart surgeries such as valve repair/replacement or coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). Concomitant ablation for AFib can restore a normal heart rhythm for many AFib patients, reducing symptoms and the need for lifelong medication.


Make An Appointment

Call 216-844-4004 to schedule an appointment with a UH atrial fibrillation surgeon today.

Find a Doctor

Quick Facts

If you’re scheduled for heart valve surgery, bypass surgery or another cardiac procedure and have atrial fibrillation, concomitant ablation may allow your surgeon to address both conditions in a single surgery. Procedure highlights include:

  • Recommended by the Society of Thoracic Surgeons as Class I (highest recommendation level) for AFib patients undergoing cardiac surgery.
  • Up to 80% of patients maintain normal heart rhythm 2–4 years after surgery.
  • Decreases your lifetime risk of stroke.
  • Same hospital stay as your primary surgery – no additional recovery period needed when integrated properly.

What Is Concomitant Surgical Ablation and How Does It Work?

Concomitant ablation for AFib is a surgical procedure performed during another open-heart surgery to restore a normal heart rhythm, reduce long-term stroke risk and improve survival.

The most common type of concomitant ablation we use to treat AFib is the GP Maze procedure, which is done under general anesthesia. It’s the preferred method of AFib treatment for patients who need additional heart procedures such as heart valve repair or CABG.

Maze surgery corrects AFib in up to 90% of patients, and many can stop taking blood thinners 3-6 months after the procedure.

How Does Maze Surgery Address AFib?

During Maze surgery, your surgeon uses radiofrequency (hot) or cryoablation (cold) energy to treat the upper chambers of the heart (atria). These energy sources create scar tissue in the heart, which prevents the triggers that cause AFib from spreading.

During the procedure, your surgeon also closes the left atrial appendage (LAA) a small pouch in the heart where blood clots often form in people with AFib. Closing the LAA has been proven to reduce the risk of AFib-related stroke by more than 90%.

Maze surgery can also be performed on its own to treat AFib in patients who don’t require other cardiac surgeries. The procedure is only considered concomitant when it is performed alongside other heart surgeries.

The control room oversees the surgical theater at University Hospitals Harrington Heart & Vascular Institute
A young female doctor checking the heartbeat rate of a senior Caucasian woman in a hospital examination room

Benefits of Concomitant Surgical Ablation

Benefits of concomitant surgical ablation include:

  • Same recovery period as primary surgery. The staged approach – where ablation is performed weeks after the primary heart surgery – requires two separate recoveries.
  • Faster AFib treatment, without medical management between surgeries.
  • Up to 80% of patients maintain normal heart rhythm 2 – 4 years after surgery.
  • Improves long-term heart rhythm control and quality of life for most patients.
  • Reduces lifetime stroke risk.

Why and When Is Concomitant Surgical Ablation Recommended?

Your UH surgical team will conduct a comprehensive evaluation to determine if concomitant ablation is appropriate for you. Ideal candidates for concomitant ablation include:

  • Patients scheduled for mitral valve surgery who have pre-existing AFib.
  • Patients undergoing aortic valve replacement or repair with AFib.
  • Patients scheduled for coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) with AFib, particularly if AFib is symptomatic or persistent.
  • Patients with longstanding persistent AFib (duration >1 year) requiring other heart surgery, who have not responded well to medication alone.
  • Patients in need of left atrial appendage (LAA) closure due to contraindications for long-term anticoagulation therapy.
  • Elderly or complex patients with heart failure, especially if the pumping ability of the heart’s left ventricle is significantly reduced.

When Might Concomitant Surgical Ablation Not Be Recommended?

Concomitant surgical ablation may not be suitable in the following cases:

  • Asymptomatic Patients: Patient who do not experience frequent or continuous AFib that significantly affects their quality of life.
  • Advanced Age With Comorbidities: The risk of performing concomitant surgical ablation may not outweigh the benefits in elderly patients who also have severe pulmonary dysfunction, renal dysfunction or some other serious comorbidity.
  • Full Medication Trial Hasn’t Been Tried Yet: Your doctor will likely not recommend surgical ablation until you’ve tried antiarrhythmic medications and those medications have either failed to control symptoms or caused intolerable side effects.
  • Severely Dilated Left Atrium: Ablation is often unsuccessful in patients with an extensively enlarged left atrium.
  • Structural and Tissue Factors: Severe atrial fibrosis, significant mitral valve incompetence and certain other underlying structural heart diseases may prohibit the use of concomitant surgical ablation.
  • High Risk Surgeries: Certain complex cardiac surgeries may cause concomitant ablation to be technically impossible or too dangerous.
  • Re-operative cardiac surgery: If you are undergoing a second or third operation on your heart, the MAZE procedure may not be done due to extensive scar tissue left after your first operations.

Only a specialist can determine if you’re a candidate for concomitant surgical ablation, so it’s important to talk to your doctor. Call 440-508-8966 to schedule an in-person or virtual appointment with a UH atrial fibrillation specialist today.

Risks of Concomitant Surgical Ablation

Concomitant ablation performed during cardiac surgery is generally safe. However, any surgical procedure carries risks that should be with your doctor, including these risks:

  • Higher likelihood of needing a permanent pacemaker.
  • A temporary increase in arrhythmias, including AFib episodes, palpitations and/or atrial tachycardia as the heart heals.
  • Postoperative bradycardia (an abnormally slow resting heart rate).
  • AFib recurrence or incomplete relief of AFib symptoms.
  • Bleeding and vascular damage, including bleeding at insertion sites, blood accumulation in the pericardial sac (the sac that encloses the heart) and damage to blood vessels.
  • Serious but rare complications include stroke and thermal injury to surrounding structures such as the pulmonary veins, esophagus and phrenic nerve.

Overall risks increase for patients in their 80s and 90s.

Concomitant Surgical Ablation Compared to Other AFib Ablation Procedures

Concomitant surgical ablation is one of several ablation options University Hospitals offers for AFib, along with catheter ablation (including radiofrequency and pulsed field ablation techniques) and a minimally invasive/robotic option called the convergent procedure.

Concomitant Surgical Ablation Catheter Ablation Convergent Procedure
Invasiveness High (open heart surgery) Low (catheter-based) Moderate (minimally invasive/robotic)
Best for AFib patients in need of heart valve repair, bypass surgery or other open heart surgeries Paroxysmal/persistent AFib Persistent/long-standing AFib
1-Year Success Rate Very High Moderate (lower in persistent AFib) High
Recovery Several weeks to months for full recovery 1-2 weeks for return to normal daily activities; 1-3 months for full healing of heart tissue 1-3 weeks for return to normal daily activities; 1-3 months for full healing of heart tissue

What Happens Before, During and After Concomitant Surgical Ablation

In concomitant surgical ablation, the primary cardiac surgery (valve repair/replacement , coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG), etc.) is generally performed after the surgical ablation.

Before

You will receive general anesthesia to put you in a sleep-like state during your surgery.

During

After opening the chest to access the heart, your surgical team will:

Your surgical team will connect you to a heart-lung bypass machine, which takes over the work of the heart and lungs during your surgery. Before completing the primary surgical procedure (valve repair/replacement, CABG, etc.), your surgeon will use special tools to apply radiofrequency (hot) or cryoablation (cold) energy to the upper chambers of the heart (atria). These energy sources create scar tissue in the heart, which blocks the triggers that cause AFib.

During the procedure, your surgeon usually will also close the left atrial appendage (LAA), a small pouch in the heart where blood clots often form in people with AFib. Closing the LAA has been proven to reduce the risk of AFib-related stroke after surgery by more than 90%.

After

After concomitant surgical ablation, you can expect to:

  • Spend one or two days in the ICU, where your vital signs will be closely monitored.
  • Spend several more days recovering in a hospital room. The exact length of your hospital stay will depend on which primary surgery you had, your present condition and other factors. Studies show that adding ablation to open heart surgery does not extend hospital stay or recovery period.
  • You may receive medication for arrhythmia (irregular heartbeat), depending on your procedure and condition. For example, arrhythmias are common after valve replacement surgery. Some patients temporarily require a pacemaker to correct an arrhythmia.
  • If you had valve replacement surgery, you will start anticoagulation therapy to reduce the risk of getting a blood clot. If you received a biological valve, you’ll likely have to stay on anticoagulation medication for up to three months. If you received a mechanical valve, you’ll need to take anticoagulation medication for life.
  • Learn about cardiac rehab, which can help recovery from valve repair/replacement surgery and CABG.
  • Learn how to care for your incision at home.

After you return home, the length of your recovery largely depends on the primary cardiac procedure you had. For example:

  • Recovery from CABG typically takes 6-12 weeks for initial healing, with full recovery generally taking several months. Most CABG patients can resume light activity and walking within 1-2 weeks after their surgery.
  • Recovery from heart valve replacement surgery typically takes 4-8 weeks for initial healing, with a full recovery often taking 2-3 months. Most heart valve replacement/repair patients can resume light activity and walking within 1-2 weeks after their surgery.

Your doctor will give you more detailed information on what to expect during your recovery. They will also tell you when you can drive, return to work and resume different levels of physical activity.

Frequently Asked Questions


Next Steps & Connect With UH

Call 216-844-4004 to schedule an in-person or virtual appointment with a UH atrial fibrillation specialist today.